Bottle photo · clone index

For men 2023 Arabic house winter

Wafa

Ard Al Zaafaran

4.19 36 votes

3.7 longevity · long lasting

2.6 projection · strong

Community-detected clone · likely

Inspired by By Kilian Black Phantom

No editorial clone list names this pairing — it comes from wearers voting "smells like" on this fragrance's own page. Counted here once enough of them agreed.

78.9% community agree 15 vs 4 votes

Wearers suggest it matches

By Kilian

Black Phantom

~€200.00 retail

Side-by-side comparison →

People say it smells like

Community “smells like” votes on this fragrance's page. The percentage is agreement, with vote counts in brackets.

By Kilian

Black Phantom

79% 15 / 19

French Avenue

Spectre Wraith

57% 4 / 7

Parfums de Marly

Carlisle

50% 2 / 4

Maison Alhambra

Tabac

50% 2 / 4

Emper

Phantom My Hero

33% 1 / 3

Sources: clone relationship from the public clone index (clonespreadsheet.com); notes, accords, ratings and vote aggregates from a Fragrantica corpus snapshot (Kaggle, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0); editor review written for this site. Community data captured 2026-09-19.